EMDR Negative Cognitions List (and Positive Cognitions) — Free PDF
A printable list of common EMDR negative cognitions (NCs) and matching positive cognitions (PCs), grouped by the three themes taught in Basic Training — responsibility, safety, and control.
Free PDF for EMDR clinicians. Get it by email.
What's in the EMDR cognitions list
Thirty-plus common NC/PC pairs organised by theme:
Responsibility — defectiveness ("I am not good enough" → "I am good enough"), responsibility — action ("It's my fault" → "I did the best I could"), safety / vulnerability ("I am in danger" → "It's over; I am safe now"), and control / choice ("I am powerless" → "I have choices now").
The PDF also lists the criteria for a workable cognition, the Phase 3 questions in paraphrased form, and the VoC (1–7) wording.
What makes a good negative cognition
Following Shapiro (2018) and Leeds (2016), a usable NC is a self-referencing, present-tense belief that is irrational in light of the facts, generalises beyond the one memory, and still feels true when the client brings up the target. A PC is the realistic, positively worded belief the client would like to hold instead.
The most common errors are accepting a feeling ("I feel scared"), a statement about someone else ("He is dangerous"), or a fact ("I was hurt") as the NC.
How clinicians use it
Keep the list beside you in Phase 3 and offer it only when the client is stuck — their own words are always preferred. It also helps in Phase 1, where grouping targets by shared NC theme makes the target sequence plan easier to build.
If a chosen PC starts with a VoC of 1, soften it ("I can learn to…") so it is believable enough to install in Phase 5.
Cognitions and core beliefs
Negative cognitions are closely related to the core beliefs described in cognitive therapy. For a downward-arrow exercise and a core-belief examples list that links into EMDR targeting, see the core beliefs worksheet.
Related on the EMDR guide
Frequently asked questions
What are negative cognitions in EMDR?
A negative cognition is the present-tense, self-referencing negative belief a client holds when they bring up a target memory — for example "I am not safe" or "I am not good enough". It is identified in Phase 3 alongside the image, emotions, SUD, and body location.
What are the three categories of EMDR cognitions?
Shapiro groups them into responsibility (defectiveness — "I am…", and action — "I did…"), safety/vulnerability, and control/choice.
Should I give clients the list?
Use it as a prompt when a client is stuck. The client's own wording is preferred, and the chosen belief must feel emotionally true to them.
What is the VoC?
The Validity of Cognition scale (Shapiro, 1989) rates how true the positive cognition feels now, from 1 (completely false) to 7 (completely true).
References
- Shapiro, F. (2018). Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) Therapy: Basic Principles, Protocols, and Procedures (3rd ed.). Guilford Press.
- Leeds, A. M. (2016). A Guide to the Standard EMDR Therapy Protocols for Clinicians, Supervisors, and Consultants (2nd ed.). Springer.
- Shapiro, F. (1989). Efficacy of the eye movement desensitization procedure in the treatment of traumatic memories. Journal of Traumatic Stress, 2(2), 199–223.