EMDR Contraindications: When to Delay Reprocessing (Clinician Guide)
Few absolute contraindications, many reasons to wait: the client safety factors to check before Phase 3, and what each one changes.
Browser-based BLS, free clinician PDFs, and EMDR Assist — the in-session companion built around the 8-phase protocol.
EMDR has few absolute contraindications, but several situations mean reprocessing should wait or be modified: current suicide risk or ongoing danger, a crisis, unscreened dissociation, medical conditions strong emotion could worsen, substance use without a plan, and upcoming court testimony. The usual response is assessment and more preparation, not refusing EMDR.
- Shapiro frames contraindications as client safety factors checked in Phase 1, not a list of conditions that rule EMDR out.
- A flagged factor usually changes when and how reprocessing starts, not whether the client can have EMDR.
- Unscreened dissociation is the factor most often missed; a DES-II below 30 does not rule it out.
- Medical issues are handled with the client's medical provider and a suitable form of bilateral stimulation.
- Processing can change how a memory is recalled, so pending testimony belongs in informed consent.
Contraindication or caution?
Very few situations rule EMDR out for good. Shapiro (2018) describes client safety factors to assess in Phase 1 history-taking, and EMDRIA's Phase One yellow flags cover several of the same areas. A flagged factor rarely means "no EMDR". It means "not reprocessing yet" or "reprocessing, but differently": more Phase 2 preparation, a medical consultation, a safety plan, a dissociation assessment, or a slower pace.
The question to ask before Phase 3 is not "is this client allowed EMDR?" but "is it safe to start reprocessing this target now, and what has to be in place first?"
The client safety factors to check
The ten areas the EMDR Assist readiness screen uses, drawn from Shapiro's client safety factors and EMDRIA's yellow flags.
| Factor | What to ask about | What it usually changes |
|---|---|---|
| Current safety and risk | Suicidal thoughts, self-harm, or current danger (for example still living with someone who is hurting them) | Review risk and the safety plan first. Reprocessing can raise distress for a while. |
| Physical health | Conditions that strong emotion could aggravate (for example heart conditions or seizures), pregnancy, or eye problems if using eye movements | Consult the client's medical provider where needed, and choose a bilateral stimulation method to suit. |
| Medication | Benzodiazepines or other recent medication changes | Benzodiazepines may reduce effectiveness for some clients (Shapiro, 2018). Note what was taken before sessions and coordinate with the prescriber. |
| Alcohol and drug use | Current use, including use to cope after hard sessions | Agree a plan for after sessions before reprocessing starts. |
| Life stability | Housing, work, relationships or a crisis right now | A crisis usually needs to settle before processing starts. |
| Support outside sessions | Someone they can reach after a hard session | Build a support step into the between-session plan. |
| Court or legal involvement | A court case, or they may need to testify about what happened | Include it in informed consent and, where relevant, talk with their lawyer before processing those memories. |
| Something they might lose by getting better | Benefits, a role in the family, or a relationship that depends on the symptoms | Talk it through openly. It often explains processing that gets stuck later. |
| Timing | A big event straight after a processing session (exams, travel, a court date) | Schedule processing away from big days, with enough time to close the session. |
| Therapeutic relationship | Do they trust you enough to tell you when it is too much? | Strengthen the relationship first. It is what makes the stop signal usable. |
Download this as a printable EMDR readiness checklist.
Dissociation: the factor most often missed
Standard EMDR assumes the client can keep one foot in the present while the memory is activated. Clients with a dissociative disorder often can't, and reprocessing without adjustments can leave them flooded or shut down. Screen in Phase 1, for example with the DES-II.
A DES-II of 30 or more is a screening cutoff, not a diagnosis: follow it with a fuller assessment, such as the MID or a structured interview (DDIS or SCID-D), before reprocessing. A score below 30 does not rule dissociation out. Leeds, Madere and Coy (2022) found the cutoff misses many dissociative disorders, so add a mental status exam and clinical interview for dissociation, and follow up high item scores and the amnesia items.
When dissociation is present, the usual path is longer stabilisation, parts-aware preparation and titrated processing, guided by the ISSTD (2011) treatment guidelines. See EMDR and dissociation.
Medical and medication considerations
Reprocessing can bring strong emotion and physical arousal. For clients with conditions that this could aggravate, such as heart conditions or seizure disorders, consult their medical provider before reprocessing. Pregnancy is not in itself a reason to refuse EMDR, but discuss it and consult the client's medical provider where needed. For eye problems or recent eye surgery, use tactile or auditory bilateral stimulation instead of eye movements.
No medication appears to block processing completely, but benzodiazepines may reduce its effectiveness for some clients (Shapiro, 2018). Note what the client took before each session and coordinate any changes with the prescriber rather than asking the client to stop.
Court cases and testimony
Reprocessing can change how a memory is recalled: images often become less vivid and the emotional charge drops. If a client may testify about an event, explain this in informed consent and, where relevant, talk with their lawyer before processing those memories. Stabilisation and work on other targets can usually go ahead while the case is open.
If a factor is flagged
Typical responses. Document the decision and the reasoning, and take hard calls to consultation.
+Current suicide risk
+Ongoing danger or an acute crisis
+DES-II 30 or more, or other signs of dissociation
+Medical condition or pregnancy
+Substance use
+Pending testimony
+Weak alliance or no support outside sessions
Over-preparing is a risk too
Preparation should be long enough but not longer. De Jongh and colleagues (2016) found no rigorous evidence that a stabilisation phase is required before trauma-focused treatment for complex PTSD. Dissociative disorders are the exception, where phase-oriented treatment is recommended. Use the safety factors to decide what must be in place, then start.
Free EMDR tools for clinicians
Browser-based BLS, free clinician PDFs, and EMDR Assist — the in-session companion built around the 8-phase protocol.
Frequently asked questions
EMDR has few absolute contraindications. Situations that call for waiting or modifying the approach include current suicide risk or ongoing danger, an acute crisis, unassessed dissociation, medical conditions that strong emotion could worsen, substance use without an after-session plan, and pending court testimony. Each is assessed in Phase 1 and usually changes when and how reprocessing starts.
Pregnancy is not in itself a reason to refuse EMDR. Discuss it with the client, consult their medical provider where needed, and weigh the intensity of the planned work.
Current suicide risk needs assessing and a written safety plan in place before reprocessing, because processing can raise distress for a while. Whether and when to proceed is a clinical judgement, best made with consultation.
No medication appears to block processing completely, but benzodiazepines may reduce effectiveness for some clients (Shapiro, 2018). Record what was taken before sessions and coordinate with the prescriber rather than stopping medication.
Yes, with a dissociation-informed approach: a fuller assessment, extended stabilisation, parts-aware preparation and titrated processing, by a clinician trained in dissociation. Standard pacing is not appropriate.
It can. Reprocessing often makes a memory less vivid and less charged. If a client may testify, cover this in informed consent and talk with their lawyer before processing those memories.
References
7 sources · peer-reviewed and clinical texts
- 1Shapiro, F. (2018). Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) Therapy: Basic Principles, Protocols, and Procedures (3rd ed.). Guilford Press.
- 2EMDR International Association. Phase One Yellow Flags (Phase One Toolkit).
- 3Leeds, A. M., Madere, J. A., & Coy, D. M. (2022). Beyond the DES-II: Screening for dissociative disorders in EMDR therapy. Journal of EMDR Practice and Research, 16(1), 25–38.
- 4International Society for the Study of Trauma and Dissociation (2011). Guidelines for treating Dissociative Identity Disorder in adults, third revision. Journal of Trauma & Dissociation, 12(2), 115–187.
- 5Stanley, B., & Brown, G. K. (2012). Safety planning intervention: A brief intervention to mitigate suicide risk. Cognitive and Behavioral Practice, 19(2), 256-264.
- 6EMDR International Association. Adapting the 8 Phases: Considerations for Working with Clients at an Elevated Risk for Suicide.
- 7de Jongh, A., Resick, P. A., Zoellner, L. A., et al. (2016). Critical analysis of the current treatment guidelines for complex PTSD in adults. Depression & Anxiety, 33(5), 359–369.
Free PDFs for this topic
Is the client ready to start reprocessing? The ten client safety factors, dual-attention capacities, a dissociation screen, red flags, and a proceed / modify / hold decision on one printable checklist.
DES-II, DES-Taxon, SDQ-20, and MID cutoffs with a Phase-4 readiness decision tree and stabilization protocol summaries (grounding, dual awareness, parts-informed). Cites Bernstein & Putnam, Nijenhuis, Dell, ISSTD, van der Hart.
Printable, state-adaptable informed consent template for EMDR — risks, benefits, alternatives, confidentiality, and signature blocks. Adapt to your jurisdiction before use.
Tools & resources
The ten client safety factors, capacities and a go / modify / hold decision on one printable sheet.
DES-II and follow-up assessment steps before reprocessing.
What clients can expect between sessions, and the red flags.
Related reading
EMDR is safe when delivered well, but it isn't consequence-free. A clear-eyed guide to side effects, dangers, who should be cautious, how long effects last, and the safeguards that prevent harm.
One reprocesses memories with bilateral stimulation; the other works with the parts of the self that carry them. How EMDR and IFS differ, and how they fit together.
Self-administered EMDR is not recommended for trauma reprocessing. Here's why — and what is safe to do alone.
A 25-minute, citation-backed clinical guide to using EMDR with Complex PTSD: phased treatment, extended stabilization, dissociation-aware adaptations, NC-cluster sequencing, realistic session counts, and what good care looks like.
The most common reason EMDR destabilizes a client is unrecognized dissociation. This guide covers spotting it in session, formal assessment, grounding techniques, parts-aware preparation, and modifications to the standard protocol.
Knipe's method for clients who lose the present during reprocessing: brief, counted contact with the memory, with bilateral stimulation strengthening the here and now.