EMDR vs IFS: Differences, Evidence and How They Work Together
One reprocesses memories with bilateral stimulation; the other works with the parts of the self that carry them. How EMDR and IFS differ, and how they fit together.
Browser-based BLS, free clinician PDFs, and EMDR Assist — the in-session companion built around the 8-phase protocol.
EMDR reprocesses distressing memories using bilateral stimulation within a structured eight-phase protocol. IFS (Internal Family Systems) works with the different "parts" of a person, helping protective parts step back so wounded parts can heal. EMDR has a much larger research base for PTSD. Many clinicians combine them, using IFS ideas to prepare clients and get past blocks in EMDR.
- EMDR targets specific memories; IFS targets the relationships between parts of the self.
- EMDR is recommended for PTSD in major treatment guidelines; IFS has a small but growing evidence base.
- IFS has no fixed protocol or bilateral stimulation; EMDR follows eight defined phases.
- The two are often combined, especially for complex trauma, where protective parts can block EMDR processing.
- Working with dissociative clients needs dissociation-specific training whichever approach is used.
What each therapy is
EMDR (Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing) was developed by Francine Shapiro. It is based on the Adaptive Information Processing model: symptoms come from memories that were never fully processed. The therapist and client pick a target memory and reprocess it with sets of bilateral stimulation (eye movements, taps or tones) across eight phases, until it no longer feels disturbing (Shapiro, 2018).
IFS (Internal Family Systems) was developed by Richard Schwartz. It sees the mind as a system of parts: exiles that carry pain from the past, and protective parts (managers and firefighters) that work to keep that pain away. Underneath is the Self, described as calm, curious and compassionate. The therapist helps the client get to know their protectors, gain their permission, and then help exiles release the burdens they carry (Schwartz & Sweezy, 2020).
EMDR and IFS at a glance
| EMDR | IFS | |
|---|---|---|
| Main idea | Unprocessed memories drive symptoms | Parts carrying old burdens drive symptoms |
| What the work focuses on | A specific target memory, present trigger or future situation | Parts of the self and the relationships between them |
| Structure | Eight defined phases, with standard measures (SUD and VoC) | A flexible sequence: find, befriend and unburden parts |
| Bilateral stimulation | Yes, central to reprocessing | No |
| Evidence for PTSD | Many randomised trials; recommended in major guidelines | Small, early studies |
| Training | EMDRIA-approved basic training | IFS Institute training levels |
What the research shows
EMDR has one of the largest evidence bases of any trauma therapy. It is recommended for PTSD by the World Health Organization (2013) and other major guidelines, and a 2024 individual participant data meta-analysis found it works about as well as other trauma-focused therapies (Wright et al., 2024). See does EMDR work? for the detail.
The IFS research base is much smaller. A randomised trial in rheumatoid arthritis found improvements in pain, depression and self-compassion (Shadick et al., 2013), and an uncontrolled pilot study of 17 adults with PTSD after childhood trauma reported large reductions in PTSD symptoms (Hodgdon et al., 2022). These results are promising, but there are not yet randomised trials of IFS for PTSD.
How clinicians combine them
Twombly and Schwartz (2008) describe how the two models fit together. A part "stuck in the past" and an unprocessed memory network can be seen as two descriptions of the same thing. In practice, clinicians use IFS ideas inside the EMDR protocol rather than replacing it:
- Before reprocessing: check whether any protective part objects to working on the target, and address its concerns first.
- When processing loops: a stuck channel is often a protector stepping in. Asking about that part can work as a cognitive interweave.
- During preparation: helping the client notice parts without becoming them builds the dual awareness EMDR needs.
The free IFS-informed EMDR guide sets out where parts language fits in each of the eight phases and where it doesn't.
Parts work and dissociation are not the same thing
Everyone has parts in the IFS sense. Dissociative disorders involve more separated parts of the personality, and need a fuller assessment and dissociation-informed treatment. Screen before reprocessing, for example with the DES-II, and see EMDR and dissociation.
Which one to choose
For PTSD after one or a few clear events, EMDR has the stronger evidence and usually works within a set number of sessions. People who feel pulled in different directions inside, or whose protective strategies get in the way of facing memories, may find IFS ideas helpful, either on their own or alongside EMDR. Many therapists are trained in both. If you are looking for a therapist, ask how they use each approach and what training they have.
Free EMDR tools for clinicians
Browser-based BLS, free clinician PDFs, and EMDR Assist — the in-session companion built around the 8-phase protocol.
Frequently asked questions
Neither is better for everyone. EMDR has much more research behind it for PTSD and is recommended in major treatment guidelines. IFS has a smaller evidence base but many clinicians find it useful for complex trauma and inner conflict.
Yes. Many clinicians use IFS ideas within EMDR, for example checking whether a protective part objects before reprocessing, or speaking to a part when processing gets stuck. Twombly and Schwartz (2008) describe this integration.
No. IFS works through focused attention and conversation with parts. Bilateral stimulation is specific to EMDR and related methods.
It has early evidence, including a randomised trial in rheumatoid arthritis (Shadick et al., 2013) and a small uncontrolled pilot study in PTSD (Hodgdon et al., 2022). Larger controlled trials are still needed.
References
7 sources · peer-reviewed and clinical texts
- 1Shapiro, F. (2018). Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) Therapy: Basic Principles, Protocols, and Procedures (3rd ed.). Guilford Press.
- 2Schwartz, R. C., & Sweezy, M. (2020). Internal family systems therapy (2nd ed.). Guilford.
- 3Twombly, J. H., & Schwartz, R. C. (2008). The integration of the Internal Family Systems model and EMDR. In C. Forgash & M. Copeley (Eds.), Healing the heart of trauma and dissociation with EMDR and ego state therapy. Springer.
- 4Shadick, N. A., Sowell, N. F., Frits, M. L., et al. (2013). A randomized controlled trial of an Internal Family Systems-based psychotherapeutic intervention on outcomes in rheumatoid arthritis: A proof-of-concept study. Journal of Rheumatology, 40(11), 1831–1841.
- 5Hodgdon, H. B., Anderson, F. G., Southwell, E., Hrubec, W., & Schwartz, R. (2022). Internal Family Systems (IFS) therapy for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) among survivors of multiple childhood trauma: A pilot effectiveness study. Journal of Aggression, Maltreatment & Trauma.
- 6World Health Organization (2013). Guidelines for the Management of Conditions Specifically Related to Stress. WHO.
- 7Wright, S. L., Karyotaki, E., Cuijpers, P., Bisson, J., Papola, D., Witteveen, A., et al. (2024). EMDR v. other psychological therapies for PTSD: A systematic review and individual participant data meta-analysis. Psychological Medicine, 54(8), 1580–1588.
Free PDFs for this topic
Combining Internal Family Systems parts work with the 8-phase protocol — phase-by-phase integration map, protector permission wording, unblending interweaves, and target sequencing rules. Cites Schwartz, Twombly & Schwartz, Knipe, Shapiro.
A printable clinician worksheet for mapping ANP/EP parts — each part's job, trigger, and fear, plus conflict mapping, cooperation contracts, target-selection rules, and stabilisation red flags. Cites van der Hart, Nijenhuis, Knipe, ISSTD.
Tools & resources
Related reading
Few absolute contraindications, many reasons to wait: the client safety factors to check before Phase 3, and what each one changes.
Both EMDR and CBT are first-line for PTSD. They work differently — and one may suit you better.
Brainspotting grew out of EMDR in 2003. Here's what brain spotting therapy shares with EMDR, where they differ, what the research says, and how to choose.
Two of the most-used body-aware trauma therapies. Here's how they differ and where they meet.
ART is a younger eye-movement therapy that diverges from EMDR in important ways. Here's how they differ.
A 25-minute, citation-backed clinical guide to using EMDR with Complex PTSD: phased treatment, extended stabilization, dissociation-aware adaptations, NC-cluster sequencing, realistic session counts, and what good care looks like.